Showing posts with label Witchcraft and Fortune Telling (Canada). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Witchcraft and Fortune Telling (Canada). Show all posts

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Criminal Code of Canada Section 365: Witchcraft & Fortune-Telling

Here is the text of Section 365 of the Criminal Code of Canada.  The law is still valid, and is the subject of the research paper I'm currently working on.

Criminal Code of Canada  (valid as of Feb. 11, 2014)

Pretending to practise witchcraft, etc.
365. Every one who fraudulently

(a) pretends to exercise or to use any kind of witchcraft, sorcery, enchantment or conjuration,
(b) undertakes, for a consideration, to tell fortunes, or
(c) pretends from his skill in or knowledge of an occult or crafty science to discover where or in what manner anything that is supposed to have been stolen or lost may be found, 

is guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction.

As an aside, I especially like the phrase "crafty science", as I've never seen that before.

Thursday, January 30, 2014

"R v. Labrosse" (1987)

R v. Labrosse, [1987] 1 S.C.R. 310.

Labrosse is the only case I'm aware of where a charge under a witchcraft or fortune-telling statute reached a country's highest court.  Unfortunately, it's rather brief and not extremely helpful in understanding the scope of the law.

The case involves a woman who told the fortune of a police officer for her normal fee of $ 15.  She was charged with violating Section 323(b) of the Criminal Code, which states in part that "Everyone who fraudulently . . . undertakes, for a consideration, to tell fortunes . . . is guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction."  At trial, the fortune-teller claimed that she actually had special powers to tell the future.  The trial judge convicted her nonetheless, stating that he didn't believe that she believed that, and that even if she did believe it, it was irrelevant to the charge.

The Supreme Court was thus asked to decide whether Section 323(b) allowed for a defence of "honest belief."  That is, does a fortune-teller "fraudulently" tell fortunes if he or she sincerely believes they have a supernatural power to do so?  The Court, however, disposed of the case without ruling conclusively on the issue, stating that because the trial judge made a factual finding that "[t]he accused knows full well that she has no basis for her claim to be able to predict what will happen in people's future" then "the defence of honest belief is not open on the facts of this case."

From this, however, (and not having read the trial court's ruling) it's not clear to me that the trial judge actually found that the defendant did not sincerely believe she could predict the future.  His statement that she knows "she has no basis for her claim" sounds more like a finding that she had no logical or evidentiary foundation to support such a belief as opposed to a factual finding that she was lying about her belief.  Thus, the trial judge's ruling was not on point to the question of whether the statute allows for an honest belief defence.  This ambiguity, however, is not noticed or discussed by the Supreme Court.

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Ontario Man Charged with Witchcraft Fraud

The Toronto Star has a story on an Ontario man named Gustavo Valencia Gomez who has been charged with the rare offence of fraudulently practising witchcraft.  According to the story, Gomez is alleged to have persuaded a 56-year-old woman that she was under a curse and that her children were in grave danger.  Allegedly, Gomez received more than $ 14,000 from the woman for a serious of spiritual interventions involving elaborate rituals to remove the curse.

The Canadian Criminal Code retains a provision specifically directed to witchcraft and fortune telling, and I think the provision raises some very interesting issues relating to freedom of religion that I hope to write about some time in the future.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Canadian Man Arrested on Charges of Witchcraft

A man in Brampton, Ontario, was arrested on Wednesday for practicing witchcraft and allegedly defrauding people who paid him to solve their problems. The National Post has a short report of the arrest.

I've always found fascinating the existence of prohibitions on witchcraft and fortune-telling in the Criminal Code, as they create some interesting issues around religious freedom, the nature of faith, and fraud. An excellent survey of Canadian caselaw on the subject can be found in Bob Tarantino's Under Arrest: Canadian Laws You Won't Believe and after I finish my dissertation on blasphemy I'd like to address the issue.